by Miraculix
I think Adam's "belief" is quite well supported by the rules:rules wrote:
If a triple 1, 2, or 3 is rolled, a Monster scores that many Victory Points [...].
and
rules wrote:
Each additional roll of that type is worth 1 extra [VP]
So in case someone rolls three "3s" and three "2s", that's a crystal clear 5 VP to me. Why? Simply check the rule:
Has a triple "1" been rolled? NO => don't score 1 VP
Has a triple "2" been rolled? YES => score 2 VP
Has a triple "3" been rolled? YES => score 3 VP
Is there any additional roll of one of "those" types? NO => don't score any extra VP
=> "score 2" AND "score 3" is definitely a "score 5" in my book! :laugh:
And whether you want to interpret six "3s" as two separate sets of three "3s" is irrelevant, as that would score 6 VP either way:
- one set of "3s" = 3 VP, plus 3 additional VPs per "3" = 6 VP
- two sets of "3s" = 3 VP x 2 = 6 VP
(I own the 1st edition of the game, btw)